A Different Thanksgiving Can Still Be a Good Thanksgiving

When you picture Thanksgiving, you probably picture more than a meal. You picture certain people, familiar recipes, and traditions you’ve repeated so many times that they feel like part of the holiday itself.

But what happens when some of those people aren’t at the table anymore? When your kids are spending Thanksgiving with their other parent? When the holiday you’re preparing for looks very different from the one you remember?

I’ve experienced all of those changes. And while I won’t tell you that different is always easy, I will tell you this: a different Thanksgiving can still be a good Thanksgiving.

How Our Turkey Olympics Began

About 15 years ago, my family started gathering in the Gainesville area for Thanksgiving. My mom had been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s and was living in a memory care community there. One of my sisters lived nearby, so my other sister, my dad, and I would travel there to celebrate together.

My mom wasn’t able to join us for Thanksgiving, but being in the same town made it easier to visit her.

Around that time, we started a tradition we called Turkey Olympics. Instead of spending the entire afternoon sitting around rubbing our bellies after a big meal, we added some games, some movement, and a little family competition.

Our gathering already looked different because my mom wasn’t at the table. There was sadness in that. But there was also room for laughter and connection.

After my mom passed away, we continued gathering in Gainesville. And we kept the Turkey Olympics.

Familiar Recipes, Changing Faces

My sisters and I had our Thanksgiving morning routine. We drank mimosas, watched the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, and prepared the meal together.

There were familiar recipes, favorite sides, and all the little things that made the day feel like ours.

Then I got divorced.

Some years, my son came to Thanksgiving with me. Other years, he spent the holiday with his dad.

It was hard not having him there. I missed him. But I could also appreciate that he needed opportunities to make Thanksgiving memories with his dad, too.

Both things were true. Understanding why we were apart didn’t make me stop wishing he were beside me.

Some years, I considered doing something completely different and taking a solo trip. So far, that hasn’t happened for Thanksgiving. But even considering it reminded me that I had choices about how to spend the day.

Four years ago, my dad passed away in February. That Thanksgiving, we gathered again. The group was smaller, and the day felt a little more somber. But we still had each other, and most of our traditions remained.

Over the years, Thanksgiving has changed through losing my mom, getting divorced, and then losing my dad. There wasn’t one big adjustment followed by everything settling into place. We’ve had to keep adjusting.

The Traditions Can Move With You

For me, Thanksgiving is very much about traditions. Sweet potato casserole. Pumpkin pie. Turkey Olympics.

But I can eat those foods and play those games any day in November.

Your Thanksgiving celebration doesn’t have to happen on the fourth Thursday in November.

If your kids are with their other parent that day, you can celebrate the weekend before or the Saturday after. You can gather in another city, invite different people, or make a smaller meal with everyone’s favorite dishes.

The date can change while the connection remains.

Maybe this year, you plan a Friendsgiving with another single parent and their kids. Each family brings a favorite dish, the kids choose a game, and you spend a few hours enjoying each other’s company.

Maybe your version of Turkey Olympics becomes the thing your kids talk about long after they’ve forgotten what you served.

Play gives everyone something to share. It can help a gathering find its own rhythm, especially when people are feeling an absence or getting used to something new.

You Don’t Have to Recreate the Whole Holiday

Here’s where I want to be honest: when I don’t have my son for Thanksgiving, we don’t move the celebration to another day.

Making all those sides for two people feels like a lot of work, and recreating the full meal hasn’t felt necessary for us.

You get to make that decision for your family, too.

You might want an alternate celebration with every traditional dish. You might want pumpkin pie and a movie. You might spend Thanksgiving with family, meet a friend, or take the trip I’ve considered but haven’t taken yet.

You can miss what the holiday used to be and still enjoy parts of what it is now. You don’t have to feel cheerful all day for the day to hold something meaningful.

Three Ways to Make Thanksgiving Your Own

  1. Choose what matters most. Ask yourself—and your kids—which parts you actually look forward to. Start with those instead of assuming you need to recreate everything.

  2. Make one plan for connection. Invite another single parent and their kids, join family, or arrange time with a friend. Give yourself something specific to look forward to.

  3. Leave room for fun. Try your own Turkey Olympics, pull out a board game, or let the kids plan an activity. You can create a memory without creating an elaborate event.

Thanksgiving has changed many times for my family. I still miss the people who aren’t there, and I still love the traditions we’ve carried forward.

This year’s gathering may look different from the one you hoped for. There can still be laughter at the table, something delicious on your plate, and moments you’re glad you showed up for.

If you’re struggling to figure out what the holidays can look like after divorce, we can work through that together. Schedule a free meet and greet, and let’s talk about what you and your family need this season.

Looking for more help navigating the holidays with your coparent? Read my previous blog, Communicating Holiday Plans After Divorce, for guidance on sharing your plans and setting expectations before the holiday pressure builds.

Next
Next

You Have a Holiday Plan. Now You Have to Communicate It.